The mission of the Guerrilla Skepticism editing team is to improve skeptical content on Wikipedia. We do this by improving pages of our skeptic spokespeople, providing noteworthy citations, and removing the unsourced claims from paranormal and pseudoscientific pages. Why? Because evidence is cool. We train – We mentor – Join us.
Calling all secularism experts. As I've been working on the ISSSC Wikipedia page, I've discovered quite a few articles about the topic of secularism. Frankly I am not an expert on the topic and really could use a hand. This page on secularism is asking for a rewrite, and hoping to recruit an expert on the topic.
I'm wary of someone who "works" for a secularism organization because of bias, but if there were several people from organizations? Or some professors that specialize in the topic?
The page is getting 30-40K hits each month and really needs help.
Do I have any volunteers to help clean up this page?
Hard to imagine anyone not following the X-Files series, and one of the creepiest characters we all loved to hate. The Smoking Man (or in our household we called him The Cancer Man). Well apparently he is William B. Davis and is a Canadian Skeptic.
I discovered this when I received a Google alert for Barry Beyerstein this week and it gave me this interview with Davis. Its all about his acting career and then a couple questions about skepticism, then on again to acting. The Got Your Wiki Back! project is all about improving the pages of our skeptical spokespeople and Davis's page badly needs it.
His page is considered a Stub which means we need someone to adopt it and improve it. Davis states in his interview... " I ended up becoming a kind of spokesman for the skeptic community. Because of The X-Files,
I had the notability, and now I had some knowledge. So I did some talks
on the subject at various places, and then Discovery Channel grabbed me
to host a couple different shows, where I’d look at paranormal events
and see what the science behind them is."
I've updated his page with a link to this article, and added an category called "Skepticism". Its just waiting for someone to start looking for these Discovery Channel shows and even some of these "talks... at various places". Someone had already added him to the Canadian Skeptic category on Wikipedia, which is nice, but if nothing is mentioned on his page, then what good is that?
BTW Davis's WP page is getting about 4 - 5 thousand hits a month. IF this page were to be awesomed up to a really nice full page we could apply for the Did You Know? front page of WP. And really get the word out.
Just checked out his FB page and it looks like he has a new book out. I think I'll write to him and see if he will send over some links to make finding the links quicker. Remember when approaching the WP subject, we have to be firm about the decisions we put in the final edit. We are trying to improve Wikipedia, and must see that as the bigger picture. But we are also looking for the skeptical slant to improve our spokespeople's pages and bring awareness to the general public about this topic.
I'm just sick over this, well not sick but pretty close to it. I've respected Anderson Cooper for years. My avatar on the JREF forums is a picture of Cooper and Browne on CNN with the screen shot that says "Dead Wrong". Cooper has always asked the hard questions and did his research, he never let anyone get away with vagueness, he slammed them to the floor. Psychics were always handled firmly.
Now this.
Anderson allowed John Edward onto his show to give readings to his mother and himself. Nothing skeptical mentioned from what I've heard. This JREF SWIFT blog sums up how I feel.
Tim Farley on October 20th SWIFT blog talks about skeptical tools to measure how successful we are. I concur we really need to be able to measure our impact. We can't keep throwing darts into the forest if we never go and look to see if we hit anything. When involved in any kind of event, there should be some discussion about how it went, what could we have done better and where did we go wrong. We need to learn, and improve.
Tim asks the question. Who of these psychics is more popular (Browne, Van Praagh or Edward)? Interesting question. Where do you concentrate your efforts if you have very limited time and resources? I'm sure there are many ways of doing this, book sales on Amazon maybe? Google search results? Tim would probably have 34 different ideas if we asked him.
Here is a simple way. Use the Wikipedia Article Statistics Tool. It only takes 1.364 seconds and you will be amazed. Keep in mind this tool has a bit of a delay. So if we want to look to see if John Edward's Wikipedia page got any hits after his Oct 14th, 2011 debut on Anderson, we can just look it up.
Generally Edward has about 600 hits a day to his Wikipedia page. On Oct 16th his page got 3.7K hits. Then the next day 3.1K, then 2.7 and finally 1.6K (maybe people were finally watching Anderson from their recording on Tivo?)
Wikipedia is a great way of judging popularity because it is accessed by the general public (believer, skeptic and fence sitter) We can assume that Wikipedia users tend to be people who have access to the Internet, and I'm only looking at WP in English.
What kinds of things are people reading on his page? There is quite a lot of skeptical content that I and other editors have left. His page is patrolled quite carefully, I am one of them and have reverted edits from skeptics many times. I've erased "he's the biggest douche in the Universe" at least 5 times this year alone, others have probably caught those edits before I got to it. (BTW this isn't guerrilla skepticism)
I'm waiting for some other source (secondary) to pick up the JREF blog post so I can (or someone else can) put the article up on Edward's page. We rather not put up primary sources if we can help it.
Lets just answer that question. Which of these psychics is more popular? Quick come up with your own guess before I reveal my answer. Using Wikipedia as a resource we can come up with a few numbers. I'm picking Sept 2011
Sylvia Browne - 14,003
John Edward - 16,244
James Van Praagh - 4,156
This just added Dec 25, 2011
22K
John Edward "fans" will read this quote from Michael Shermer this month
"Pretending that the dead are gathering in a television studio in New
York to talk twaddle with a former ballroom-dance instructor is an
insult to the intelligence and humanity of the living".
Quite a mouthful, further known on this page as ISSSC. I received an email from CFI announcing a new Director, Barry Kosmin. The email sat in my inbox for a week or so before I had time to read it over and see if I needed to update a WP page or two.
I had not know of Kosmin or the ISSSC before, but I have known of the American Religious Identification Survey as I'm sure all you good skeptics have as well. This is the group that every 20 years asks the question "When you die will you want a religious funeral?" and other questions in order to judge the religiously of Americas population. Remember all the discussion of the new category "none"? Yep, that's the study that had us all talking.
Well I tried to look for Barry Kosmin's WP page as he is the author of 20 books on secularism and religion, and the founder of the ISSSC. Seems like someone that should have his own page, guess not. While searching for him on WP I found the page for the ISSSC and boy was that disappointing. There were 4 flags on the page dating from 2008 for problems with formatting,notability, quoting primary sources and the like. The two links to the ISSSC's own webpages were broken. What a waste!
I ventured over to the ISSSC's web pages and followed the links they gave there to the media and so on and read a few articles about Kosmin. Sounds like a pretty fascinating guy, too bad no one in our community has his Wiki back! As I keep saying, it is extremely important that our spokespeople AND our organizations have well tended Wikipedia pages. I know, I know these people/organizations have great websites. Yes, that is true, but don't tell me. The world is visiting these WP pages and are looking for answers to their questions. Often times the WP page gets the same page rating on a search as the main website. Are we going to continue to allow the world to view these nasty WP pages, letting them think that they have so little importance and credibility that the community that should support them, doesn't?
As I was saying, I spent about an hour reading over the articles on the ISSSC's page and cleaned up their WP page as best I could. I removed one of the four flags at the top of the page. There remains a lot to do. They need more references to outside sources that mention their relevance. The page needs an info box along with all the details. I think it even needs a picture or two, if not of the building/office then maybe at one of their functions, even when they are at a lecture somewhere. Does someone have a picture they can upload?
Oodles remain to be done, but there is a big difference from what I found to what I left. Here is a couple hours ago. And here is the current page. Maybe someone from the ISSSC could contact me at susangerbic@yahoo.com or leave a comment here pointing me in the direction of where I can find more citations. (WP does not want you to work on your own page) And if there are problems with how the page currently looks then please also bring that to my attention.
I was forwarded a link to the Wyndgate Country Club vs Richard Dawkins and CFI-Michigan from Wikipedia editor Linda Long. I had already seen this link and really didn't think much could be made of it. It isn't like Dawkins has never seen criticism, so I looked over his page and decided that it just wouldn't fit into his article. Today I got another link from someone, this time with a YouTube video of Sean Faircloth and Dawkins on Fox news.
I decided that there is plenty of media focusing on this right now. Protests at the Country Club (yeah team!) and possibly some legal action by CFI. So I left mainly the same blurb on Richard Dawkins, Sean Faircloth, The Magic of Reality: How We Know What's Really Trueand CFI's Wikipedia pages.
Its current news right now, so this should go up. I did a lot of linking between the 4 pages so they should be getting hits to each other. I also didn't use just one citation, I listed 4 citations. Check out these pages.
I'm really sad that the Wyndgate Country Club does not have its own page. I know they are really hating all this publicity right at the moment, they refuse to comment according to the newspapers. But I would have loved to have left the same blurb on their site.
Hits wise we are talking quite a lot. Between the four sites over 107K each month. This controversy didn't hurt hits to Dawkins page. Normally he gets 4-5K hits a day. There is a big jump to 6.2K and 5.4K during this time. A 38% jump. Sean Faircloth's Wikipedia page had a 50% spike in hits for one day. CFI didn't see a rise in numbers. The book The Magic of Reality: How We Know What's Really True saw a 65% increase in hits to his page.
On another note... When I was looking over the books page trying to decide if I should include it in all the edits. I noticed an editor leave a note on the discussion page, Sept 21, 2011 "Can we prepare for a WP:DYK for this article?" Ahhh "no" These have to be launched within days of the launching of the page. What a missed opportunity. I left a snarky remark in response.
If I might paraphrase Wikipedia editor Dustin Phillips who says he got into editing Wikipedia because he kept putting up great links on his Facebook page to share with his skeptic friends, after awhile it seemed to make more sense to put those same links up on Wikipedia so everyone could see them. Exactly.
Posting links for your friends is a good idea. A better idea is to get the links in a place that the world can enjoy. A place that holds an encyclopedic hold on our hearts and knowledge. Maybe a place like Wikipedia?
Found this link left on Mark Edward's Facebook page today and I knew exactly who needed to be reading it. Yep you know where.
So I read through all the links on the page (thank you DJ for including so many). I went through every single link and made a nice paragraph that could be inserted on the pages of Van Praagh, Sylvia Browne, Carla Baron, John Edward and Alison DuBois. I just changed a few words here and there to make it fit nicely into their pages.
On Van Praagh's page I went a bit farther. Because of the links that DJ left in the Huffington Post I was able to add two awesome YouTube videos to his page. I didn't label them as "failures" like the videos state, but just mentioned one as "Van Praagh often appears in the media to promote his group readings,
seminars and workshops. One such appearance on the TV show "The Circle"
shows Van Praagh giving a 5 minute reading to several audience members". The 5 minute reading is pretty horrible to watch BTW. I didn't put these two sentences under criticism/skepticism but under the category of "Career as a Medium", mainly because I don't want to give my opinion that it is a failure of a reading, I'm just letting the viewer decide. I'm sure true believers will think he did rather well (he did seem to get a few hits) and they might say that they know he is for real because sometimes he has a bad day.
In another link I wrote a completely separate paragraph about a medical statement he made about Barbara Walters. He told her that she had elevated white blood cells, she went to the doctor and found out that her blood was normal. She states on the video that what he told her is harmful. So I left that video for his fans as well.
I'm sure that the JREF's exposure on TIME.com, ABC, Nightline, AOL, Huffington Post and on and on will get more readers than my few paragraphs on the psychics pages on Wikipedia. But they work together, people go specifically to Wikipedia to learn about these people, and will look at the references left.
What kind of numbers are we talking about anyway? Lets look at only Sept 2011 and see what kinds of hits we can expect Oct 2011 will get.
James Van Praagh - 4,156
Carla Baron - 718
John Edward - 16,244
Sylvia Browne - 14,003
Alison DuBois - 263
So about 35K people are looking at these pages each month. That's quite a lot when you think it just took me about an hour to update these pages. Almost a half a million will view these citations in a years time. Also leaving these citations exposes readers to our skeptical spokespeople, publications and organizations, that is a win for Guerrilla Skepticism!
So keep this in mind the next time you paste a link to your Facebook page or Twitter feed. That's nice and keeping your friends informed is a good thing. But if you aren't willing to take an hour once in awhile to edit that link into Wikipedia, then maybe you should bring it to the attention of someone who will.
Seriously think about this next statement of mine. Are you a skeptic, part of the skeptical community? Fine, hang out, share links, socialize and bitch about stuff. Or are you a part of the skeptical movement? If so, what are you doing? If you are in the movement then you need to start doing so.
Love Skype! Just had my first Wikipedia centered Skype conversation with Dustin and Lei. They were good sports being from Kentucky and Arkansas and I'm in California, a really late call for them. John was unable to make the call due to illness but he gave us several questions to discuss, so he was with us in spirit. I want to share some of the conversation with you.
We talked about why we edit, and some of our projects. Dustin said he feels like "a part of a team" and thinks that having a conversation once a month or so will keep him motivated to edit. Lei started out editing Wikipedia after hearing Tim Farley talk about why it is so important. Tim had asked for help on researching obscure topics which Lei found interesting, eventually she felt she could start helping more by actually editing.
We discussed why more people in the skeptical movement don't edit, even though we keep hearing that this is a great project? I think we decided that most people don't know where to begin, the project is really big and daunting. Dustin said that some of his skeptic friends have given up editing Wikipedia because there is so much to do and it is never ending, which is what attracts Dustin.
Both Dustin and Lei are involved in skeptic meetups, but felt that this project satisfied their love of research. Dustin felt that he was already posting science links to Facebook, taking those same links and putting them into Wikipedia would reach a much larger audience than just his Facebook friends.
Having others to talk to was what was most important on this call, we discussed how we never get feedback from what we leave in these articles. No one is going to write to us and say "thanks for that critical thinking link you left, really changed my mind" anymore than someone would write to a dictionary or a print encyclopedia. But still this is how minds are changed, by allowing them to do their own research.
Lei is all over the "We Got Your Wiki Back" project and reverts vandalism several times a week for our skeptical spokespeople's pages. She just reverted one for George Hrab a couple days ago by viewing her watchlist. When I noticed her revert and mentioned it to her, she wrote back "I've got his Wiki back!" Too funny.
She is also trying to clean-up the page for J. T. Eberhard who will be speaking at Skepticon in a few weeks. She knows that his page will be getting a lot of hits when it gets close to the date. She has emailed him asking for some info but he has not responded. Very frustrating.
While looking at these pages we noticed that the Flying Spaghetti Monster has his own page. I had no idea. Check out that page, really well cited. Someone took some real care creating this page. When you go there you might want to know that this is accessed over 100K times a month. Amazing! In fact in July it hit 291,747. July 2011 "this article ranked 3,622 in traffic on en.wikipedia.org". You can see this here.
Dustin and I both shared how awesome it feels when you leave a really good blurb, correctly cited in a place where their is little critical thinking. He had been looking for a way to reference some of Ben Radford's work, and came across an article Radford had published on spontaneous human combustion. I'm really proud that Dustin is helping out with this project, he really understands what I'm advocating. Here is his reference, look under possible causes. Awesome right?
As I said, John could not make our call. But we talked about how we might help him on his Wikipedia project. John is a professor in Washington and teaches a freshman class on critical thinking. John is working as a Wikipedia Ambassador which tries to teach college students how to edit Wikipedia. John has them pick skeptical topics like UFO's, mediums, lake monsters ect to either clean up the existing page or start a new page. He has made all the students make user pages with a very short bio. Dustin, Lei and I divided up the students and will contact them on their talk pages, welcoming them to Wikipedia editing and letting them know we will help them if they need it. There are several I'm really interested in, one is writing on ectoplasm. How can you not love this project! Ectoplasm as a homework assignment?!?
The Ambassador project is sponsored by Wikipedia, it trains and supports the educators. John said he got to spend a weekend at one of the nearby colleges with food and training. He loved it and highly encourages others to volunteer.
Soooo I'm always open to other editors (or wannabe editors) to write to me here or by email at susangerbic@yahoo.com. I'm willing to help you in anyway I can. I would also love to have more of these Skype Wikipedia conversations if others are interested. We can set it up by time zone to be more effective. Just let me know if interested.
Amazing what you can find on Wikipedia. After having a conversation with UFO expert Robert Sheaffer I started browsing around at various UFO pages. Easy to do when you find a category page. You can usually find these at the very bottom of a page. Category UFO sightings This is a easy to use way of browsing.
I think these pages can be excellent example of how to write a Wikipedia page. You have to be clear, just the facts. You must have citations. They must be noteworthy (not just something you saw out your bathroom window, but others need to have experienced it and it must have been something reported in the media). These should be interesting to read, while still stating the facts. There is nothing wrong with quoting people in the articles you read, there is something wrong with you drawing conclusions from the eye-witnesses that isn't stated in the citation. You have to remain neutral in your writing. You can not state your opinion, let the experts do that for you.
We can quote specific investigators that have published citations. I'm looking forward to Sheaffer's new bookPsychic Vibrations: Skeptical Giggles from the Skeptical Inquirer. We should be able to find all kinds of references that we can add to these UFO pages in it. External links, quotes and so on. My point being that you don't have to go out and find a ton of references to add to one page (yes if you are creating a page from scratch) but sometimes it is easier to find an article or book you are enjoying. Then try and find ways of using that one reference in many different Wikipedia pages. When I get Sheaffer's book I can look though it and see if he mentions specifically some of the UFO events that are reported on Wikipedia. Then I can take the exact same citation and paste it in after whatever blurb I'm writing for that UFO page. Use your time wisely, and more importantly enjoy what you are reading.
I just added "Psychic Vibrations" to the UFO skeptical books to read area. At the moment there are only 4 books on the skeptical list. There is a large list of "General" books, a couple by Sheaffer. I left a note on the discussion/talk page asking how these books are categorized, who decides. Maybe we should just make all the books general?
One of our very own editors John Farquhar created as his first ever Wikipedia page after reading a blog by Tim Farley. Vancouver, Washington UFO Sighting - Lets take a quick look at it.
Just the facts in the leed "The Vancouver, Washington UFO sighting occurred over two evenings in February 2011 as reported by many eyewitnesses in the Clear Meadows neighborhood of Vancouver",
complete with a citation to the newspaper article.
Description of Events: again really nice, to the point. Quoting what is reported. I think I like that John is not quoting the people. I suppose it is a matter of opinion but having too many people saying "I have no idea what I saw!" and "it was just amazing, like nothing I've ever experienced!" might lead the reader on. Love this line "Due to the hand-held motion of the camera and the absence of any
background imagery, size and movements are very difficult to determine." This is skepticism without being blatant about it. I doubt it will be challenged but if it were, then simply find an expert to quote.
Possible explanations follows. Good job writing what could have been the answer, Sirius, then quoting the expert as saying, that can't be right because of .... Again John is showing how there can be many explanations more likely than proof of aliens. Skeptics can be wrong, we admit that. Sometimes we make statements that when more evidence comes forward we acknowledge it and keep thinking.
John then follows up with what probably the UFO actually was (I'll let you read it yourself) he even presents citations showing how this has been the case in other UFO sightings.
Anyone not following how important editing Wikipedia for skeptical content is? This is our chance to neutrally get the message out that investigation is fun. Finding out how it was probably done is cool, way better than conspiracy stories of NASA and Martians implanting us with embryos. To someone with their faculties still in place this is an example of a great UFO investigation, clearly written and now out there so the world can read it and learn.
Interesting discussion this morning with an academic about improving scientific pages on Wikipedia. This professor writes "I never met a single scientist who'd spent time on a wikipedia entry.
They just don't have the time for that sort of thing (and having tried, I
can tell then it isn't a job to be undertaken lightly!). For example,
many of my colleagues have commented on how poor the entry on
acetylcholine is. None has bothered to spend the week it would take to
rewrite it properly (and then, it seems, go through interminable
wrangles too)"
Interesting point! But what I'm understanding here is that academics can not be bothered to improve the pages to educate the rest of us. The hoop-jumping and "wrangles" that are needed on Wikipedia might be overwhelming indeed, but it is what it is. Yes, it can be confusing. Yes, it isn't probably what your used to in academia. But it is important and it needs to be done.
I have been involved in the skeptical community since 2000. The argument I keep hearing as to why our population is so scientifically illiterate is because scientists do not come out of their labs (and towers) long enough to explain to the rest of us what they are doing, in easy to understand words. Science is awesome! But non-scientists like myself don't always get that. Yes, some scientists are not "people persons" and probably are best not lecturing in our children's classrooms. We all have our skills.
I don't know how prevalent it is to respond to the above statement that scientists don't edit Wikipedia? I'm hoping that isn't true. Wikipedia readers are going to go to these scientific sites for information. That is a fact. What they find when they get there is probably all they are going to look at, if it is not correct (or incomplete) this is all the knowledge they are going to get. Is that really in the best interest for our population?
I can spent two minutes on any psychic Wikipedia page and find the woo. No problem. I can spend two days looking over a page like Acetylcholine and not discover one problem. We need our academics. Please don't be frustrated with Wikipedia rules. Ask someone for help.
Let me try one last appeal to our scientists...
Acetylcholine - 63,750 hits in one month Glutamic acid - 34,564 hits in one month neuroscience - 36,151 hits in one month stem cell - 89,676 hits in one month
Makes
you really think doesn't it? Usually when someone wants to make a
difference they write a blog or a paper for publishing, that article is
normally read only by like-minded people who are already on the
bandwagon. How often do we get to really speak to fence-sitters? Think
about it, 90K a month are going to the stem cell page hoping to
understand what it is that their co-worker is going on and on about.
They aren't going to read an academic paper, they want to understand
"does it work?" "can it harm me?" and they want to know quickly. If
they want further information THEN with some knowledge they can follow
the links at the bottom of the page to the academic papers and blogs and
so on. That is how we change minds and make a difference in the
world.
Do you really want non-academics editing these pages? Please consider sharing your knowledge on Wikipedia.
One more thing... here is a blog written by female scientists who got together for a science editing session. "... we discussed the experience of being a graduate student and how writing for Wikipedia compares to teaching undergraduates."
Was referred to one of our skeptical spokespeople today, who in his frustration tried to edit his own Wikipedia page. He used his own name and made it clear on the talk page that he was doing so to clear up problems associated with his page. Wikipedia considers this a no-no.
He writes, "I'd thought for ages that my wiki page was very unbalanced so I decided, at last, to do something about it.. What I don't understand is that, if I don't fill in the details, who will?" And he is correct.
We need to be out there looking out for these people, not everyone is aware of the We Got Your Wiki Back! project. Please get the word out, we can't let them directly edit their own page, but we can help them by listening to their concerns, discussing the changes on the talk page and reading over all the links (ect...) that they can give us. Everything has to be vetted, your reputation as a editor is also on the line. You can't just put up whatever someone says, you need to go to the source and read it yourself. When the citation says "accessed on date" that isn't only a check to make sure the link works, but a way of saying "I went here on this day..."
Do let the subject your working on know you are doing so. It is important to them to know that someone cares and is watching their back. Listen to them, they might be able to give you some great articles to read that you can cite.
They probably aren't aware of the rules to editing Wikipedia, they may not understand that you will have to really edit down their suggestions to just a sentence or two. Reassure them that a well written blurb may lead the reader to check out the cite and follow it to the real article.
New project for Guerrilla Skepticism
I've been thinking about this for some time and want to share my thought process with you. In the town I live in, Salinas, nearly half of the population speaks Spanish. I speak Spanish in the context of my work as a photographer, understanding or speaking outside work is not so great. But the idea that there are other languages people communicate in is a constant reality.
As some of you may know, I'mveryactive with the Independent Investigations Group (IIG). I like to know if things we are doing work, and love feedback and stats. At the beginning on my involvement with the IIG and Wikipedia editing, I kept analyzing the amount of hits generated directly from Wikipedia to the IIG website, and what pages/topics were sending us the hits. Overwhelmingly every month it was (and still is) anything to do with UFOs and Billy Meyer. I noted that a lot of these hits are coming from Wikipedia Japan.
I must admit that I'm not the quickest thinker, it takes me awhile to get-it. I asked Robert Sheaffer who writes the Psychic Vibrations column for SI (here is his new book) "why are the Japanese so fascinated by UFO's?" His answer "I really don't know why the Japanese are hitting your links big-time. Yes,
they are UFO-crazy, but then so are the French, Belgians, Chinese, Brazilians, Mexicans, Americans, Brits, and practically any other country you care to mention." That answer really got me thinking, why then were we getting so many hits to www.iigwest.org from Wikipedia in Japanese? (I'm sure you are all already there with the correct answer, remember I'm slow about this)
Could it possibly be that the IIG does not have a reference on other language's UFO Wikipedia pages? Do other languages have UFO Wikipedia pages? If they do have a page, is critical thinking represented well? What about all the other pseudoscience topics? If the English version is in such dire need of help, I can only imagine what the non-English ones might be like. I believe that the English speaking countries have more skeptical organizations hosting skeptical events. This outlet allows us to socialize and network with like-minded thinkers thus creating tons of podcasts, blogs and media to other English speakers. What must it be like to live in Uganda or Equator as a skeptic? No TAM like events happening down there that I know of. Maybe because they don't have the social distractions we have they are more likely to DO SOMETHING for the skeptical cause? Maybe they have already picked up on editing Wikipedia for skeptical content and have been doing so aggressively prior to Tim Farley's call to edit ? I just don't know.
So here is what I'm proposing. We are a very talented bunch, I know we have access to lots of skeptics that can read/write in many languages. Why not take a short "call to action" and translate it into as many languages we can, and then post it back on this blog for people to copy/paste and send to any non-English speaking skeptical blogs/podcasts/individuals/groups we can find? It won't be something that can be managed by me, I won't be writing any blogs in Tagalog in the near future, and don't really care for the Babel Fish translations of pages. But maybe someone in the Philippines or elsewhere will see the call-out and pick up from there?
People of the world deserve to have access to well written and correctly cited, skeptical articles just as much as the English speaking world. Please help if you can. The following is what should be translated (not verbatim but its context). The two paragraphs below that probably do not need to be translated (but it could be summed up as instructions to pass on)
For fun I've included a few Wikipedia pages in different languages along with September 2011's stats for that page.
A call out for skeptics/critical thinkers to edit Wikipedia for factual content.
Guerrilla Skepticism is the act of
inserting well written, carefully cited skeptical/scientific references into
Wikipedia pages that need critical thinking, while still following
the guidelines and rules to make it into everyone’s online
encyclopedia. This grassroots method allows skeptics working at home
the ability to contribute to the skeptical movement without
personally confronting people.
Wikipedia users will find references to
skeptical articles that they can follow or not. Changing a mind can
be a slow process, facts stacked onto more facts. When they begin to
question they will start to search the Internet for answers.
Wikipedia will be there waiting for them with no eye-witness
anecdotal opinions, and no one in your face telling you how stupid
your beliefs are. We will go a lot farther changing minds when the
person is doing their own research which will allow them to set aside
their cognitive dissonance and celebrate critical thinking with a
clearer mind.
For more information visit http://guerrillaskepticismonwikipedia.blogspot.com/
As a English speaker I have been
focusing just on the English version of Wikipedia. Now it is time to
broaden our scope, Wikipedia readers in every language deserve to
have only facts on the pages they are visiting. This means we need
volunteers to translate the above two paragraphs into whatever
languages we can and send to critical thinking groups for publication.
This could be newsletters, blogs, podcasts whatever media that will
get the attention of critical thinking editors willing to help edit
Wikipedia for skeptical/scientific/critical thinking content.
If you can read/write in another
language, and can translate the above two paragraphs into explaining
the goal (not just a direct translation) please do so and email back
to me at susangerbic@yahoo.com.
If you know of any non-English speaking places that the translated
"call to action" can be sent, please also email names/links to me.
I'm sure after they get a extra long night of sleep the crew of The Skeptics' Guide to the Universe podcast will be evaluating their first ever 24-hour podcast extravaganza. Steven Novella stated that their goal was to raise critical thinking levels with a dose of skepticism and science (I'm paraphrasing here). They had a meter that they checked every so often that went from red to green. I have no idea how they were measuring this gauge or if it was just a prop for the show, but what Novella is advocating is exactly what I have been blogging about for the last few months.
Increasing awareness of skepticism/critical thinking/science is good for society. A win-win for everyone!
There are many ways to achieve this goal, the SGU felt it could help out our cause by staying awake for 24 hours and letting the world watch them do it. Maybe it helped? There were thousands of views, and tons of tweets everywhere. It certainly made people talk and engage with each other, thats all a good thing strengthening our community. I managed to make it through about 4 hours on Friday night and about 3 hours before and after work on Saturday.
During the hours I watched I managed to get some quick Wikipedia editing done (as I noted in the comments of this blog) Dustin scored a couple great updates to Boiron and Oscillococcinum's pages. Lei finished up Vashti McCollum's page, and I'm hoping others were editing away while listening also. I tweeted the Wikipedia edits as they were being finished on the SGU24 tweet, the JREF and Tim Farley re-tweeted a few times. All good. I didn't get any comments from the watchers or the SGU (as far as I know) who were following the tweets. I'll try not to be cynical, but the chat room and the tweets seemed more concerned with the social aspect of the whole event (like how much bacon they could eat) and as I said, bringing us together is a good thing. Personally I would have liked to see them suggest things for the community to do...write letters, tutor a child, sponsor a classroom... edit Wikipedia for skeptical content... you know things that really improve critical thinking.
I believe that when someone is in the media's eye and the listener is not sure who they are, or wants to refresh their memory of the person, they are going to turn to the Internet to fill them in. When typing in that name, usually within the first few hits they will see a link to a Wikipedia page (if that person is noteworthy enough to have a page). For many reasons (people are familiar with Wikipedia, no popups, no virus, easy to use, neutral and usually sums up the person in a few paragraphs) most people will click on the Wikipedia link before they go to a "personal" website. Maybe after reading the Wikipedia page they will follow the links to other websites. I don't have access to their websites sats, but if they are curious about their hits from Wiki most webservices will tell them where they are receiving "referrals" from.
I thought it might be interesting to see what kind of hits came in to the "skeptical spokespeople"'s Wikipedia pages for 9/23. The site I'm using is something you can use also. http://stats.grok.se/ There is a delay in recording the numbers and I might be premature blogging too early. The delay might be as much as a day, depending on time zones and maybe other things. We can look at these same Wiki pages in a day or so and see that we can see.
I'm not going to give the real numbers (don't want to turn this into a popularity contest, if you want to know how many hits a site gets, you can plug them into the Wikipedia article traffic statistics tool. Everything is in percentage based on what is considered normal for Sept 2011.
SGU - +300%
Rebecca Watson - +216%
Steven Novella - +300%
Jamy Ian Swiss - +430%
Richard Saunders - +180%
George Hrab - +34%
Adam Savage - +152%
Tim Minchin - no increase (may be too early to look at his results)
Is this totally scientific? No. Lots of things might be affecting these numbers. But it is interesting.
I mention all this not just because I want more people to get involved in doing something to help out the skeptical cause by editing Wikipedia for skeptical content. But because we need to make sure we have the backs of our skeptical spokespeople. They represent us! When people go to their pages, they will be exposed to other skeptical/science/critical thinking hyperlinks that they may follow and read. They may also click on the links at the bottom of the Wikipedia page (the external links and further reading links).
This is a part of guerrilla skepticism and just plain common sense. We need to make sure these pages are in order, well written, current, engaging and so on. You can help, please help, there is so much that needs to be done. Open a Wikipedia account, ask for help, read this blog for ideas, whatever it takes. Just join the cause and help.
Note!
Our very own Karen Stollznow will be appearing on Anderson Cooper's talk show on October 10th. She says that she was only one of several people all talking about the harm that psychics cause. She didn't get to say a lot, but she is going to be our spokesperson for those few comments. And when people google her (and you know they will) they will find that we have her skeptic back!
FYI this blog discusses the stats after the NBC Nightline "Beyond Belief" show that the JREF recently did.
Steven Novella and the Skeptics Guide to the Universe tonight begins a 24-Hour Podcasting Show. He states that critical thinking is at an all time low (he even has a meter to prove it!) He wants to try and raise the level of science and skepticism during the next 24-hours to at least the yellow level. I'm challenging anyone listening the next 24-hours to listen in, and really DO SOMETHING to raise the level of critical thinking in the public. Edit Wikipedia for skeptical content.
Join me, sign into your Wikipedia account and help edit. I'm going to be giving updates in the comment section of the edits I do tonight.
Heres a great place to start...
I love the category function on Wikipedia. I've talked a lot about this on earlier blogs about using the Skeptics by country page as a way of finding skeptic pages that badly need work. Putting them in the category has been discussed as well.
As you know from reading the last few blogs, I'm on this kick to find more paranormal pages that are making claims like "medium XYZ has solved many missing person cases" and "the police call in ABC whenever they have a mystery to solve". You know that kind of thing. Then when you look at the citations you discover that the citation might not even be there, or is a bad cite (dead link, or links to the psychic's website ect...).
Well trolling around Wikipedia does give you all kinds of strange pages, but I thought why not just go to the psychic's pages from the category page that someone put them in? Great idea. I've collected a few of the category pages and pasted them for you below. Remember there might be a lot more, I just haven't found them yet.
Just a quick mention that here is a wonderful opportunity for someone wanting to edit Wikipedia in support of the JREF.
Just got this email from them that lists all the citations with them in the news lately! Designed just for us. Well not really, but it is perfect for working backwards (having the article, writing the citation then putting it in Wiki)
My last blog dealing with the deletion of a uncited non noteworthy psychic named Jackie Barrett, made me think that there might be others like her. Up, just as some kind of advertising. Face it, being able to state "I'm on Wikipedia" gives credibility. I'm really disappointed with Wikipedia that they allow this kind of thing to happen. I assume that there aren't enough volunteer editors out there looking for this kind of thing. I guess that is why we need to get on the job.
It appears that any con-artist can whip out a page, and get it past the editors. Lots of people post stubs, thinking they will get back to it soon. Well sometimes they do, and sometimes they don't. Whether this is well-meaning or just laziness can be argued all night.
Guerrilla Skepticism isn't just leaving well-cited references that have a skeptical slant, but checking sources for paranormal claims. I keep finding this kind of crap, " working with clients and also with law enforcement. She has worked alongside district attorneys, law enforcement, and America's Most Wanted to help solve case files across the United States." as I found on Barrett's page. The citations that were left to prove this were from her own blog and website. WHAT!
Here I am preaching over and over that you must cite carefully and only noteworthy citations and people are getting away with this thing. Okay, need to calm down and get to my point.
It isn't just the psychic grief vampires, I'm sure this is happening in the alt med world as well as all the pseudoscience areas. I just happen to troll the psychic pages so I'm more likely to notice it. John Farquher and I are working (slowly) on the psychic detective page and I've started looking at existing citations a little closer.
Noticed this on psychic detectives...
"The Australian Sensing Murder
television series features self-described psychics assisting with
unsolved murder cases. Although the psychics have been able to
anticipate some facts known only to the police, none of the cases have
been solved, over four seasons."
No citation, so this will be removed. But it made me curious what is this Sensing Murder show?
Found this in the lead paragraph.
The psychics have not managed to solve any of the cases, although they have uncovered facts that only police knew about.[dubious– discuss]
They have in some cases provided actual names of persons related to the
area the crime was committed to police, names of persons confirmed by
serving or ex-serving police officers to have existed and resided in
close proximity to locations of crimes around the time they were
committed.[citation needed]
One thing that is really frustrating me is that some editor on
Wikipedia is flagging these things, then not going back to check up it. Doesn't the editor make some kind of note, mental or otherwise to check up? The Jackie Barrett page was flagged in 2007.
Reading over the citations it appears that all are from TV.com which lists all the episodes. Then there are a few that have dead links.
. NZ Reality TV. Retrieved 5 October 2007.[dead link]
Really makes you wonder?
So what to do? Does this page deserve to remain on Wikipedia? I'm going to go through it again and remove anything not cited, or has a broken link and see what is left.
Back on the psychic detective page I notice this reference to the police calling in psychic Debbie Malone. The citation did not include a URL, but I managed to search and find it anyway. The article is vague with little skepticism. I expanded on the blurb which was originally only this "The NSW Police Forces' Missing Unit has referred families of missing persons to psychic Debbie Malone."
The NSW Police Forces' Missing Persons Unit has referred families of
missing persons to psychic Debbie Malone, one Former Detective
Senior-Constable Jeffrey Little felt her description of what happened
was "exceptional". While other NSW officers felt she had not helped
solve any cases. Sergeant Gae Crea and Detective Sergeant Damian Loone,
state that she did not give us anything the police and the public didn't
already know. Crea recounts "I've dealt with a lot of psychics, but no
one has ever said, 'I can see where the body is buried and I'll take you
there'"
I'm of half a mind to remove the entire blurb. It has been 3 years since this happened. If this woman had any special ability and was assisting the police then surly she should have some media attention? At least her own Wiki page? But no.
So removed the uncited nonsense from the beginning paragraph on Sensing Murder's page. A blue hyperlink caught my eye for one of the psychics that appeared on the show. Haven't looked at it yet... what do you think we will find?
Deb Webber
Well it is quite critical of her.
On 13 August 2004 Australian Channel 7
broadcast a show called "Caught on Hidden Camera", in which they asked
Deb Webber to give readings to three people. The three asked to contact
deceased relatives that did not exist. Deb Webber claimed she was able
to 'contact' these people.
But following the citations which really there is only one you find this edit that leads to a skeptical site that is now defunk. To be fair this reference to her being busted on TV cannot remain if there is no citation for it. This is just going to have to wait for me or SOMEONE reading this to take care of.
I think I will have to sleep on these edits, just too late right now to make good editing decisions. I am not the only person out there in the skeptical community capable of making these edits. If you are interested in taking this on, then simply do so. If you want help or advise please comment and I will make sure you get the help you need.
We must be vigilant, we need your help. Please please please make it a point to help edit. If you lack these skills and do not want to learn them, then spend a few minutes stumbling through Wikipedia clicking on links. If you find something suspicious please just post here. Someone will take a serious look at it. Shame on us for allowing this to continue.
It all started with a mess of newspaper articles that I just can't get myself to recycle. I just finished up James Underdown's Wikipedia page and have some leftover articles I didn't use. I don't like just filing things away somewhere as I doubt I will get back to it anytime soon, usually it just gets covered up with more stuff. Well reading through one article by the Chicago Tribune from 2007 I was struck by some really great quotes by the author of the article Larry Potash.
I had used one of the quotes on the main psychic page, but I want to use more of this article. Pure gold, and I hate to just toss it. Thankfully I found the article on-line so you all can follow along. This is an example of working backwards. Start with the noteworthy article and then try to find a place to put it.
I had used the beginning of the article for the psychic page.
Concerning the television psychics, James Underdown
states that testing psychics in a studio setting is difficult as there
are too many areas to control, the psychic could be getting help from
anyone on the set. The editor controls everything, they can make a
psychic look superior or ridiculous depending on direction from the
producer. In an Independent Investigation Group IIG expose of John Edward and James Van Praagh
they discovered that what was actually said on the tape day, and what
was broadcast to the public were "substantially different in the
accuracy. They're getting rid of the wrong guesses... Once you pull back
the curtain and see how it's done, it's not impressive at all.
But love this part.
Psychics don't seem to rely on their "powers" to detect their own cancer
-- they go to the doctor, like the rest of us. They don't predict when
the train will arrive -- they look at the train schedule. And even
psychics (along with everyone else) can guess correctly now and then.
But under scientific scrutiny, and incorporating statistical
probability, no psychic has met the test.
When producers see that psychics aren't making the grade, I fear they
may lower the bar in their testing methods or simply elevate the
psychics' performance through creative editing.
In the end, the psychic phenomenon you see on TV will only be an illusion, much like it is in real life.
Great isn't it? But where to put it? I can't add more to the psychic page, that would just be too much, besides I would really like to quote him, and that is Really too much.
So I reread the article again and realized that its about a TV show called America's Psychic Challenge.
Do they have a Wikipedia page? Yep they do. (while searching for this page I found another one Paranormal Challenge I'm going to save that for another blog I think).
Looks like the winner from the first (and apparently only season) was Michelle Whitedove, who is not noteworthy enough to have her own Wikipedia page BTW. ("yes" I guess I am turning into a bit of a snob, but it seems to me that someone who can communicate with dead people should be changing the world of science as we know it) Looks like she won $100K so maybe she is just being really frugal and making the money last?
This page seems to be neutral enough, but a stub. So what to do? Is it even worth the effort? I'm sure you know the answer already, of course it is relevant. If it is on Wikipedia then even if they receive zero hits, it still needs to be done. Tomorrow might be the day that it receives thousands of hits. Actually this page gets about 1,000 a month.
Noticing that there is a wiki hyperlink to this person Jackie Barrett who was the runner up. More on Jackie later.
Now I'm reviewing the page more in detail. I think that the present tense should be changed to past tense. Also note that this is here List of prizes for evidence of the paranormal and no one seems to have noticed or cared. Looking at the discussion page someone in 2008 wrote that they edited to eliminate the awful pro-bias of the article. And someone in 2010 removed a link to a broken URL. That's all the conversation going on there, so I don't feel any need to write there with my proposed changes. Doubt anyone would get back to me in a timely manner.
So after playing with it for a bit here is what I came up with.
Reporter Larry Potash writing for the Chicago Tribune
states that paranormal reality shows like APC are cheap to produce
which means we will probably see more of them. Potash contacted James Underdown from the Independent Investigation Group IIG
who says that the TV set is a horrible place to test a psychic. There
are too many things to control, you can't know if the psychic is
receiving help from an audience member or someone working on the crew.
Potash believes that psychics are not so psychic when the cameras are
off, they "go to the doctor... look at train schedules" just like
everyone else. Psychics sometimes do guess correctly, "but under
scientific scrutiny, and incorporating statistical probability no
psychic has ever met the test". He worries that when producers see that
the psychic isn't showing spectacular results, they may lower the
testing bar or "elevate the psychic's performance through creative
editing". Underdown states "Once you pull back the curtain and see how
it's done, it's not impressive at all."
This is Wikipedia, if you can write this better please do so, won't hurt my feelings at all. I took the same citation from the psychic page, changed the access date to today (because I did access it).
On to Jackie Barrett's page. Yikes! The discussion page says that this is written like an advertisement, boy is that true. The citation that states she has worked with law enforcement is from her own blog. Another reference is to her website. There is a critical heading, but it is empty.
I'm going to look into it a bit further and see what was going on. That seemed to be happening really quickly. Well Irishguy has retired, but he lists all the pages he created and Jamy Ian Swiss was one of those pages. Interesting, and he is the person who removed Jackie Barrett's page from deletion. Tiggerjay, is into editing anything Disney and edits here and there. The page creator is Lyndela, who does not have a editor page.
Looking over the page again I note that there are only 5 references. One is her personal website, one is her blog, one is a video that no longer exists, one is a reference on a website showing that she has been on a ghost hunt and lastly the only credible one is the reference to the show America's Psychic Challenge. And LOL just clicked on that link and it does not exist anymore. Boy it sure helps to check out the references they leave.
So as far as I'm concerned this page should be deleted. She is getting 100-400 hits a month. Not very noteworthy for someone who is psychic. Now how to delete a page? No idea.
Took me awhile to find this instruction page. Guess you all are going to be following me through this process. It says that there are 3 steps. Leave this template {{Tfd|{{subst:PAGENAME}}}} on the discussion page you want removed. Okay so far so good.
Next I follow a link and put this at the top of the page
{{subst:Tfd2|TemplateName|text=Why you think the template should be deleted. ~~~~}}
The page has only 5 sources One is her personal website, one is her
blog, one is a video that no longer exists, one is a reference on a
website showing that she has been on a ghost hunt and lastly the only
credible one is the reference to the show America's Psychic Challenge
that she was on and the link is broken. This person does not fit
Notability standards. Her one claim to fame is that she was the runner
up on the aforementioned APC, the winner of that show and the other
contestants do not have Wikipedia pages. The show host John Burke does
not even have a WP page.
(sorry this is my first attempt at asking for a deletion, I see that
it is in red when I preview my edit, but can't figure out how to fix it,
I'm trying to do it just like the Big Sky one below)Sgerbic (talk) 05:49, 20 September 2011 (UTC)
Here on this blog it looks like the links are all in blue, there when I click preview there is a lot of red. I tried over and over and could not figure it out.
For my future reference (and possibly yours) here is the html of what I wrote.
==[[Template:Jackie Barrett]]==
{{Tfd2|Jackie Barrett|text=The page has only 5 sources}} One is her personal website, one is her blog, one is a video that no longer exists, one is a reference on a website showing that she has been on a ghost hunt and lastly the only credible one is the reference to the show [[America's Psychic Challenge]] that she was on and the link is broken. This person does not fit Notability standards. Her one claim to fame is that she was the runner up on the aforementioned APC, the winner of that show and the other contestants do not have Wikipedia pages. The show host John Burke does not even have a WP page.
(sorry this is my first attempt at asking for a deletion, I see that it is in red when I preview my edit, but can't figure out how to fix it, I'm trying to do it just like the Big Sky one below)~~~~
Now I have to go to the user page who first launched the page and let them know what I'm doing. Lyndela does not have a user page, but I went to the discussion page for her non-existent user page and left the message that I have requested its deletion and why. It appears that I went to the right place because the other time in 2007 someone left her the same message (but more official). At no time did Lyndela respond. Wonder if she has done any editing other than this page? I clicked on the "contrubutions" next to her user name on the history of Jackie Barrott's page. Here is what I got. Looks like she has only made three edits in total.
Pretty interesting page that user page. Put any editor's name in that box and you can see all the edits they have been making.
So now I'm done. We have been learning together tonight. All this just because of a few sentences from a newspaper article I wanted to squeeze one more edit from. I'll report back on what happens to the deletion of Jackie Barrett's page.
This just in from a WP editor...
You chose the wrong deletion method. (Not a surprise. There are a gazillion of them) WP:TFD is Templates for deletion. You were wanting an article deleted. So you wanted one of the three deletion systems that can delete articles. WP:AFD, WP:PROD, and WP:CSD.
Those are Articles For Deletion, Proposed Deletion, and Speedy
Deletion. The one closest to the TFD that you tried to use is AFD. Your
TFD debate was removed from TFD soon after you entered it, but was
started as an AFD discussion for you. (Wikipedians can be quite helpful
when they want to be. :) ) Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackie Barrett is the link to the full AFD discussion.
For future reference, the differences in the three article deletion
methods are: CSD is Speedy deletion. It is for extremely limited
criteria. If the situation does not exactly meet one of the CSD
criteria, then speedy deletion *cannot* be used. OTOH, it is the fastest
criteria. Admins like me can apply it at will if we find an article
that we think meets the criteria. And anyone can tag for speedy
deletion, and an admin will deal with it fairly rapidly. This is what
you saw in the older history of the article you want deleted. Someone
thought that the article met a speedy deletion criteria, tagged it as
such, but someone else (usually but not always an admin) came along and
disagreed and declined the CSD deletion.
In this particular case the reason was Notability. The bar to avoid
speedy deletion is much much lower than the bar to avoid it in a full
debate. An article really only needs to assert notability in some vague
way to avoid speedy notability deletion.
Next deletion method is WP:PROD. Prod is intended for uncontroversial
deletions. You can use (almost) any reasoning in your PROD deletion
request. The key though is that it only takes a single protest of a PROD
deletion to invalidate PROD deletion for that article. PROD is thus
fairly simple, but if anyone disagrees, they are free to remove the PROD
deletion notice.
Last is AFD. Articles for Deletion. This is where you launch a full
deletion debate on the article. This is what you tried to do with your
deletion attempt. Except for using the wrong system, I think you made a
pretty good deletion argument. :)
There are also deletion systems for Templates (WP:TFD), Categories (WP:CFD), Redirects (WP:RFD), Files/Images(WP:FFD), and Misc (WP:MFD). I likely missed a few in this list. So there's no real surprise that you missed the correct one on your first try. :) - TexasAndroid (talk) 21:40, 22 September 2011 (UTC)
UPDATE on Jan 9, 2012
Today is clean out my computer day. Went to Facebook and realized that there are "hidden" messages there that I have never seen. One was from Jackie Barrett (who is calling herself Joanne, but posting from Jackie Barrett's FB account)
Here is what she told me the responses...
Sept 25, 2011
"Hello, I am writing you in regards to Jackie Barett's wiki page it has
come to my attention that you have marked the page for deletion I would
like to address this. If you are not aware Jackie is the author of 2
published books , holds both a captains badge and FBI badge for her work
she has done on cold cases, on the tv show Medium P.I the captain of
cold cases Sean Crowley of NYPD stated that Jackie has worked with him
on hundreds of cases. She also was featured on AE special titled the
Amityville The Final testament , has appeared on an episode on WE tv
Secret Lives Of Woman. She has a long list of media appearances so to
correct you in your statement that the only notable apparance was
Americas Psychic Challenge you are not correct in this statement. So for
future reference before trying to delete an informative wiki page about
a person that is notable you should research further. Thank you Joanne"
my response today...
"Just now noticing this Joanne (or are you Jackie?)
Wikipedia
does not do all the work looking for the citations. If the notoriety
and citations are not on the page then the page has to be deleted.
The problem is that the page was not informative. You can't just make
these claims on a FB message page, there must be evidence of what you
are saying.
Also all discussions like this one should be done
publicly on the deletion page (which is now closed) or on my talk page
on Wikipedia.
I would love to see this captians badge and FBI
badge. Is there a URL that can prove they exist? If so it will be the
first time I've ever heard of a psychic receiving some kind of
recognition from the police."
Her response...
"Well you obviously have not done your research have fun policing wiki lol"
As usual the psychic is making a claim that they can not (or will not?) back up. People have to understand that on Wikipedia and when trying to make a claim elsewhere you have to back it up. Some seem to think that the burden to prove something does not exist relies on the skeptic. Why can't they understand this? If you are making a claim, then it has to be backed up in order for it to be taken seriously.
I don't want to have a back and forth with this person who isn't even clever enough to hide her identity on FB. Maybe I should look into this Sean Crowley of NYPD person? Here he is now as a PI. It gets more interesting, here she is appearing with Crowley for some radio show. I'm thankful that Jackie/Joanne brought this to my attention.
So working backwards here is a project that someone might be interested in tackling. Keeping in mind that Wikipedia Editors are a bit nervous about me sending a bunch of skeptics over to a page for some of this "guerrilla skepticism" stuff. I think it is called "sandbagging". Anyway, this arrived in my email a few weeks ago and I thought it might be useful but never got to it.
CFI and CSI Petition FDA to Take Action on Homeopathic Drugs
Apparently CFI and CSI have this going in a press release. Here is the link to the article. I haven't looked into it in great depth, so I'm not sure that a press release is a good citation. There may be links to follow that will get you to something more noteworthy. Remember a secondary cite is better. Don't quote the person writing the blog/petition/press release but quote the newspaper/journal/TV news show that quotes the primary cite.
Anyway, I think a mention on the Boiron and the Oscillococcinum pages might be warranted. Its not every day they get such attention from skeptical groups...or maybe they do? If so why isn't there already a bunch of mentions on their pages? We can't just assume that the public knows as much as we do about these products.
Bioron gets about 1,000 hits a month, and Oscillococcinum gets 7,000-8,000 hits a month. I would avoid the homeopathy page unless you have a really awesome citation and blub. That is a well-watched page and the editors have worked long and hard coming to some kind of agreement about what should be on the page. Before editing homeopathy (which is semi-protected) discuss what you want to do on the discussion page, listen to the comments from the other editors. BTW homeopathy gets about 90,000 hits a month, so people are clearly interested in this topic and coming to Wikipedia for answers.
And don't just stop there, I'm sure there are a lot more places the citation can be used, with slight modifications to the blurb left on the page. There are a lot of "fringe" smaller pages that the public is reviewing and we need to make sure they are getting the entire picture.
Remember editing on Wikipedia needs to be neutral, let the article speak for you. Less is more sometimes and make sure the citation is really good. Think about the importance of this, over 1 million people are reading the homeopathy page each year, do you think that a well-written blog/podcast on that subject would reach that many people? No pressure or anything.
Just found a nice article by Brian Dunning from 2007 about Wikipedia. While the topic is about finding good quality journal articles, he quickly moves into his opinion, "start with Wikipedia."
Many Wikipedia articles
end up being the closest thing to an authoritative consensus that
we have on a given subject. Each article continually improves over time until
it becomes what Wikipedia describes as the "ideal" article: "balanced,
neutral and encyclopedic, containing notable, verifiable knowledge."
Note that I'm no doubt going to be criticized for pointing laypeople toward
Wikipedia as a starting point for research, mainly due to the usual criticisms
of Wikipedia. But, as I said before, Wikipedia's weakness is also its strength,
and I do stand by this recommendation, especially for laypeople of a given
subject who don't otherwise have the experience to choose a good starting point.